I’ve often answered “yes” to this question. But am I?
Well, I believe there are qualities that just “are”. I can’t say if they’re material or immaterial but they’re made of the stuff that words just don’t do justice for.
So are those spiritual things? Maybe metaphysical. Maybe they’re more or less interchangeable concepts.
t I’ve always had the same problem. I know there’s qualities whose origins are uncertain. Maybe they just “are”. Maybe they emerge but even that which something emerges from has qualities too. Are those spiritual things? No idea.