She’s really good at what she does. She covers interesting topics too.
I’ve been a fan of David Kellog Lewis as “most flexible view” for a long time — and can cover human, animal and alien alike in a broad sense if I wanted to.
But a page into a paper she wrote in 1978 she did what nobody else could: Convinced me that David Lewis has a fundamental flaw and that is not properly addressing principals and real world contingencies.
I’d still use Lewis as a great scratchboard that is big enough for any and every philosophical view to fit in.
But for “let’s get real here”, Professor Holly Smith is the winner.